Supreme Court Reverses Billion-Dollar Copyright Verdict, Holds Internet Service Provider Is Not Contributorily Liable for Subscribers’ Infringement

Blog Post

A unanimous Supreme Court ruled that Cox Communications, Inc. (“Cox”), an internet service provider (“ISP”), is not contributorily liable for copyright infringement merely because it provided Internet service with the knowledge that it could be used by some subscribers to infringe copyrights.

The Court held that the provider of a service is contributorily liable for a subscriber’s infringement only if it intended its service to be used for infringement. That intent can be established in only two ways: first, by showing that the provider affirmatively induced the infringement; or second, by showing that the provider sold a service that is tailored to infringement, meaning that it is not capable of substantial or commercially significant non-infringing uses.

Applying this framework, the Court found that Cox did not intend for its service to be used to commit copyright infringement, and it therefore could not be held contributorily liable for its subscribers’ infringement. As to inducement, the Court found that Cox did not encourage its subscribers to infringe in any manner; to the contrary, Cox repeatedly discouraged copyright infringement by sending warnings, suspending services, and terminating accounts. The Court further found that the Internet is used for many purposes other than copyright infringement, and is therefore not a service “tailored to” infringement.

The Court also rejected the lead argument of the copyright holder, Sony. Specifically, Sony argued that the Digital Millennium Copyright Act’s (“DMCA”) safe harbor provision, which shields ISPs from secondary liability if they implement policies for terminating repeat infringers in appropriate circumstances, would be rendered meaningless if ISPs are not liable for servicing known infringers. The Court disagreed, noting that the DMCA does not expressly impose liability on ISPs who serve known infringers, and in fact expressly provides that failure to qualify for the safe harbor does not weigh against a defense that the service provider’s conduct is not infringing.

Justice Sotomayor concurred in the judgment, and Justice Jackson joined. While agreeing that Cox is not liable on the facts of this case, Justice Sotomayor criticized the majority for unnecessarily limiting secondary liability to circumstances involving inducement or a service tailored to inducement. The Court’s precedents, in the concurrence’s view, left open the possibility that other common law theories such as aiding and abetting could apply in the copyright context. The concurrence opined that the majority’s rigid two-part framework renders the safe harbor provisions in the DCMA effectively obsolete, because ISPs no longer face any realistic probability of secondary liability regardless of whether they take steps to address infringement on their networks.

Nevertheless, Justice Sotomayor agreed that Sony could not prove that Cox had the requisite intent to aid copyright infringement. Among other things, Justice Sotomayor agreed that Cox could not have had the requisite intent to aid infringement because Cox could only identify the accounts used to commit infringement, not the specific individuals using the accounts to commit infringement. Plaintiffs had, at most, shown that Cox was “indifferent” to infringement on its network, which is insufficient for aiding-and-abetting liability.

The Court’s decision carries significant practical consequences for Internet service providers and copyright holders alike. For ISPs, the decision provides substantial insulation from secondary copyright liability. Under the majority’s framework, ISPs cannot be held contributorily liable for their subscribers’ infringement unless they actively induce that infringement or provide a service specifically tailored to facilitate it. Because Internet access is plainly capable of substantial non-infringing uses, ISPs should not face contributory liability based on their mere awareness that some subscribers use their service to infringe copyrights.

For copyright holders, however, the decision narrows the available avenues for combating large-scale online infringement. The strategy of pursuing ISPs as secondary infringers has been effectively foreclosed absent evidence of active inducement or a service designed for infringement. Copyright owners will need to consider alternative enforcement strategies, including direct actions against individual infringers.

Follow Quarles

Subscribe Media Contact
Back to Main Content

Quarles & Brady LLP Cookie Preference Center

Your Privacy

Necessary Cookies

Necessary cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. You may disable these by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Always Active

Necessary cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. These cookies may only be disabled by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.

Functional Cookies

Always Active

Some functions of the site require remembering user choices, for example your cookie preference, or keyword search highlighting. These do not store any personal information.

Form Submissions

Always Active

When submitting your data, for example on a contact form or event registration, a cookie might be used to monitor the state of your submission across pages.

Analytical Cookies

Analytical cookies help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage. We access and process information from these cookies at an aggregate level.

Powered by Firmseek